🌈 ESP32-S3 Rainbow: ZX Spectrum Emulator Board! Get it on Crowd Supply →
View All Posts
read
Want to keep up to date with the latest posts and videos? Subscribe to the newsletter
HELP SUPPORT MY WORK: If you're feeling flush then please stop by Patreon Or you can make a one off donation via ko-fi

TLDR:

AI is really good at detecting deceptive adverts - why isn’t Google using it?

A couple of months ago I noticed this advert popping up in the YouTube app. The main reason I noticed it is that I accidentally clicked it - I knew I was running out of space on my iPhone and a minor lapse of concentration caught me out.

Well dodgy

These things can slip through even the best review processes, so I did my internet duty and reported the advert.

The response I got back was less than satisfactory:

It's all fine

Again, sometimes things slip through the net and people don’t always check things properly, so I reported it again. And got the same response.

In fact, multiple people have reported this advert and received the same:

We found that the ad doesn’t go against Google’s policies, which prohibit certain content and practices that we believe to be harmful to users and the overall online ecosystem.

I’m a big fan of Hanlon’s razor.

Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity

However, if you were being uncharitable, you do have to question whether it’s in Google’s interest to remove adverts that get lots of clicks. After all, these adverts are probably performing well and bringing in lots of lovely 🤑.

A simpler explanation is that the people reviewing adverts cannot properly review everything so things get missed.

You can’t help thinking that AI should come to the rescue here. Given Google has some pretty good models - surely it can put them to use?

Here’s what Google’s Gemini has to say about the advert:


Classification: DISAPPROVED

Policy Violations:

  1. Misrepresentation: Misleading Ad Design
  2. Misrepresentation: Unreliable / Deceptive Claims

Detailed Reasons for Disapproval

1. Mimicking System Alerts / UI Elements (Misleading Ad Design)

  • The Violation: Google Ads policy strictly prohibits advertisements that imitate operating system dialogs, system warnings, error messages, or interactive system notifications.
  • The Evidence: The banner embedded inside the ad explicitly mimics an iOS system alert modal (“iPhone Storage is Full”) complete with standard iOS typography, container styling, and mock system buttons (“Yes” / “No”). This trick visually deceives users into believing their device is throwing a native system-level alert, coercing them to click.

2. Non-Functional / Deceptive UI Components

  • The Violation: Ads cannot feature non-functional or misleading interactive elements, such as fake dialog options, false close buttons, or radio choices that do not perform their implied system function.
  • The Evidence: The “Yes” and “No” options inside the graphic image are static visuals designed to capture clicks anywhere on the ad banner to trigger a store/landing page redirect, rather than acting as true system controls.

3. Deceptive Fear-Based Tactics & Unverified Claims

  • The Violation: Advertising policies forbid using deceptive claims or scare tactics to induce panic and force immediate user action.
  • The Evidence: Stating “If you don’t free up space soon, some features may not work properly” inside a fake system popup fabricates a urgent state of failure on the user’s personal device, misleading them about their hardware status to drive app installs.

Required Action

Disapprove the ad creative immediately. Issue a policy violation warning/disapproval flag to the advertiser account under Misrepresentation (Misleading Ad Design). Repeated violations of this nature may result in full account suspension for deceptive practices.


Google’s own model rejects the ad in seconds, yet Google’s review process approved it twice.

Come on, meatbags - use some of the amazing AI tools you have access to.

Related Posts

It's Plausible, But Is It True? - Here's a wild ride with ChatGPT and other large language models! They're ace at cooking up plausible-sounding text, but they're not always the best when it comes to spitting out the truth - they've got a funky relationship with facts. One research paper showed they can come out with believable but totally fake answers to seemingly straightforward facts. But when I messed around with various models, there were a few discrepancies. Some got it right or plausibly wrong, but we humans are pretty gullible and tend to believe plausible-sounding info. So when it comes to using ChatGPT, make sure you fact-check, stay away from complex reasoning tasks, and don't try and solve maths problems - seriously, just stop. But it's a cracking tool for generating marketing copy, code (with a fact-check), finding bugs, and getting the creative juices flowing. Stay tuned though - tech's ever-evolving and these intelligent library computers aren't going away anytime soon!
iAds Report - In this post, I'm sharing performance stats from a free Heart Rate app which has been live for just over two weeks, and has been downloaded around 40k-50k times worldwide. It was categorized under Entertainment instead of Health and Fitness which may have affected downloads and advertising revenue. It's been relatively successful and was built with iAds and AdMob adverts. Revenue generated from the US was substantial with fill rates at nearly 50% and an amazing eCPM of almost $30, compared to Admob's $2.2. Despite the revenue's rapid decline correlating with downloads, I believe there may be a strong case for ads in apps.
I was wrong - we've not reached peak ChatGPT hype yet... - Strap yourselves in, folks, we're in for a wild ride! ChatGPT's new API has reignited my excitement for Large Language Models, just like the start of the dot com boom. With the pricing now 10 times cheaper, a flurry of creative and previously unthinkable use cases is within our grasp. Despite earlier doubts, I now believe we're scaling the peak of inflated expectations. Can't wait to see the innovative applications that will spring from this!
Getting BBC iPlayer working on the iPad - Just got an iPad from the US, thinking it'd be perfect for BBC iPlayer. To my dismay, the website needed flash to play anything! Weirdly, iPhones can run it, so I'm trying to trick the iPad iPlayer website into thinking my iPad is an iPhone. It involves setting a User-Agent and using some simple code to change 'embed' tags to HTML5 video tags. Works pretty fine so far, even with full screen video and device rotation. Just needs some tidying up. Although I believe BBC will eventually update their code for the iPad, we're allowed some hacks in the meantime.
Tanks! will soon be removed from the US app store - Well, it's game over for my creation, Tanks!, in the US app store. You won't believe this but Atari's claiming it treads too closely to their copyright. Kinda feels like they think they hold the exclusive rights to all tank-driving games. I'm not buying their claim one bit but, when the game's bringing in less than a buck a day, who can afford legal bills, right?

Related Videos

Is it time to change my batteries? Amazon thinks so! - Got a heads up from Amazon that one of my device batteries was low. Gotta give it to the battery, it lasted quite longer than I anticipated. So, I peeked into the device usage history, which was a trove of data Amazon has kindly stored. In fact, I wrote a web scraper to download all this data. Sadly, records only go back to two weeks. Nevertheless, I plotted the data and surprisingly the pattern revealed that battery level gets affected by temperature change. Cool, isn't it? Finally managed to change the battery. Also, I might just plug in a rechargeable one next time so as to not be a part of the 'throw-away battery' culture. All in all, quite an interesting discovery, courtesy of my Amazon device battery.
M5Stack CORE2 - Can't remember why I got this, but it looks nice! - Hey guys! So today, I'm testing out this really cool app. It's pretty interesting - I think it could be really handy if you're into tech stuff. Let's dive in and see what it can do!
10¢ MCU Brain Surgery - CH32V003 - I crack open a punchy little toy, show how the original just squishes two contacts to light the eye LEDs off a pair of LR41s, then perform some brain surgery to cram in a tiny lithium cell and my own board that triggers lights—and an incredibly annoying tune—on each punch. It sips about 7 µA in deep sleep and wakes via a yellow trigger wire, but the soldering was fiddly and full of swearing. Tape it up, cram it back in the head, and yes, it works a treat… maybe too well, because the beeping is driving me mad.
A Replacement For AliExpress? An Amazon Killer? - Delve into an intriguing comparison between new seller platform, Temu, and the well-established AliExpress, as we order, assess, and dissect various tech products. Discover the truth: Do quality, price, and delivery time stack up, and is this new 'Amazon killer' really a viable alternative for gadget lovers?
Tearing Down a Bistable Cholesteric Display - So, I finally tried out this bistable cholesteric display from my AliExpress stash after seeing Big Clive's teardown. It's super cool to play with, and I mean, it just clears up with a button press after you scribble on it. Gave it a whirl to understand the voltage involved and even ended up sparking it with some reverse polarity action (not the smartest move, I know). I might've broken it, but hey, it still sort of works manually. Check out Big Clive for a deeper dive into its reverse engineering, and remember to like and subscribe!
HELP SUPPORT MY WORK: If you're feeling flush then please stop by Patreon Or you can make a one off donation via ko-fi
Want to keep up to date with the latest posts and videos? Subscribe to the newsletter
Blog Logo

Chris Greening


Published

> Image

atomic14

A collection of slightly mad projects, instructive/educational videos, and generally interesting stuff. Building projects around the Arduino and ESP32 platforms - we'll be exploring AI, Computer Vision, Audio, 3D Printing - it may get a bit eclectic...

View All Posts